Reserva Privada by Rodriguez Cigars

The Leaf

Country of Origin: Nicaragua

Factory: Rodriguez Cigars (Key West, Florida)

Wrapper: 4-Year Aged Ecuadorian Connecticut

Binder: Nicaraguan

Filler: Nicaraguan

Size: 6 1/4 x 52 (Torpedo)

Body: Mild to Medium

Strength: Mild

Purchased At: Creekside Cigar Co.

Personal Rating: 7.75 / 10 — A Decent Tale

If you like this, you might also like: Plasencia Reserva Original, My Father Connecticut, Illusione Rothchildes CT

What We Do Here

The beauty of cigars isn’t just in the smoke... it’s in the ritual, the memory, the lore. Each review starts with the basics: how it smokes, how it tastes, whether it’s worth lighting up again or buying a box. Then, for those chasing the full story, we peel back the layers, deeper notes, subtleties, and the craft behind the leaf. At the end, we leave you with a little folklore to match the mood. Because around here, the smoke always carries a story.

Casual Take

This one’s soft-spoken but steady. It lights up easily and delivers a smooth, mellow profile right out of the gate. You’ll likely notice hay and roasted peanut, the kind of classic flavors that make this a solid morning smoke. The finish is clean, and the smoke is smooth with just enough flavor to keep things interesting without overwhelming your palate. Nothing flashy, just a dependable, easygoing cigar.

Deep Burn

The Rodriguez Reserva Privada starts off clean and crisp, introducing toasted peanut and sun-dried hay and those familiar Connecticut notes, but with a little more warmth. The Ecuadorian wrapper brings that signature soft creaminess to the draw, while the Nicaraguan core adds a backbone of mellow strength that hums just under the surface.

As it burns into the second third, the texture thickens slightly. There’s still that consistent peanut note, but now joined by faint cereal grain and dry toast. Retrohale brings a whisper of white pepper albeit very restrained, but it is there to wake things up just enough.

In the final third, the cigar leans back into its core identity: soft, bready, and gently nutty. There's no harshness or big transition here, just a slow fade out of mild wood, peanut shells, and a clean finish. It's the kind of cigar that doesn’t beg for attention but still earns its place in your rotation if you're after subtle, old-school charm.

The Heart of the Leaf

This cigar isn’t looking to impress with complexity. It’s more about execution and balance. For fans of milder, traditional cigars, the Rodriguez Reserva Privada brings a nostalgic quality in an unpretentious blend that pairs well with a quiet morning or a casual evening wind down. The 7.75 rating reflects its honesty: not groundbreaking, but comforting, familiar and well executed.

---

The Lore

They say he still watches. Long before tourists flocked to Duval Street and cruise ships bobbed in the harbor, there was a boy named Robert Eugene Otto. A child who lived in a grand old house on Eaton Street and a doll. Handmade. Child sized. Stitched from cloth. Stuffed with straw. Given as a gift by a servant who was said to dabble in voodoo. Robert named the doll after himself. “Robert.” And from the moment the doll arrived, things were never the same.

Neighbors claimed they saw the doll moving from window to window when no one was home. Eugene’s parents heard him talking to it late at night and sometimes, they swore, another voice answered. Objects moved, voices whispered, and tempers flared. As the years passed, Eugene kept the doll. Even as an adult. Even when he returned to that old house with a wife. The doll had a room of its own. Today, Robert the Doll resides in the East Martello Museum, locked in a glass case. Visitors must ask permission before taking a photo or risk a cursed misfortune. Letters from those who didn’t still arrive by the dozens, begging Robert for forgiveness.

It’s a quiet reminder that not all hauntings come in shadowy figures or sudden screams. Some just sit there. Waiting. Watching. Remembering.

The cigar in this review was paid for by me.

Find It Here!